Training your dog can seem like an uphill struggle at times.
One of the most frustrating habits to correct is excessive and inappropriate barking so what can you do to fight back?
Well, the obvious solution is to invest in a training collar but this can be incredibly confusing if you don’t know what you’re looking for.
Luckily, we’re here today to guide you every step of the way. Since there are so many different collars up for grabs, we’ll be spending quite some time explaining these various training methods. By the time you hit out top 10 reviews, you should be well-placed to decide which type of training would work best for your dog.
To get things started, you need to think about the different types of training collar so you can determine which would most suit your pooch.
MeetYourDog is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.
I. Our Top 5 Picks for Anti Bark Collars
- [su_label type=”success”]Our #1 Pick:[/su_label]Dog Care Rechargeable Shock Collar at Amazon
- Best Static Bark Collar: SportDOG No-Bark 10R Collar at Amazon
- Best Spray Anti Bark Collar: PetSafe Remote Pet Spray Trainer at Amazon
- Best Budget: DogRook Bark Collar at Amazon
- Best for Small Dogs: PetSafe Elite Bark Control Collar at Amazon
II. What Kind of Bark Collars Are There?
Here are the main types of no-bark training collars:
- Vibration Collar
- Ultrasonic Device
- Static Shock Collar
- Spray Collar
1. Vibration Collar
A vibration collar comes with sensors that pick up when your dog is barking too much.
This type of collar works well if you don’t want to subject your dog to any pain at all. Instead, a vibrating pulse should teach him the error of his ways humanely.
2. Ultrasonic Device
Whether in the form of a collar or handheld device, these units emit ultrasonic sound that’s inaudible to you but remarkably annoying for your dog.
Again, this form of collar uses no painful correction at all.
3. Static Shock Collar
The most popular training collars, static shock models are not to every pet owner’s liking. Fortunately, you have plenty of choice if you don’t want to train your pooch with static correction.
As with vibration collars, you’ll get onboard sensors that detect your dog’s vocal chords moving. In place of vibration, though, a gentle static shock is administered. This is roughly in line with the static shock you get from touching metal after walking on deep pile carpet.
4. Spray Collar
Spray collars discharge a metered dose of citronella spray or unscented liquid soaking your dog’s snout if she barks too much. Dogs despise the smell of citrus and don’t much appreciate wet noses either.
This training solution is tailor-made for small or timid pooches.
Make sure you factor in the cost of replacing the cartridges and ensure you can get a ready supply.
III. Is It Safe To Use a Bark Collar?
So, this is perhaps the most crucial question of all…
Is it really safe to use a bark collar.
Well, regardless of the type of training collar you use, all are considered safe. Your dog won’t come to any harm at all even if you opt for the most extreme type of collar with static shock. These are still humane even if they’re not to every pet owner’s taste.
The most accurate way of examining this question is to glance again at each type of collar and rate them in descending order of dog-friendliness.
Note: This rundown does not account for how effective the training collar is, simply how little discomfort it induces in your dog.
- Static Shock Collar: While technically termed humane, a static shock collar will create most discomfort for your pet by buzzing him with a low-level but noticeable shock
- Vibration Collar: While unpleasant, your dog won’t be in any pain as a result of the vibration kicked out by this type of collar
- Spray Collar: Although your dog won’t be joyous at a wet and lemon-scented snout, this is slight discomfort rather than pain
- Ultrasonic Device: The noises emitted by these devices should annoy your dog without hurting his ears so this is definitely the most humane of all training methods
If you have an always-on collar, you should not leave this on for longer than 12 hours in one stretch. You should also make sure the collar has adequate safety functions baked in so your dog won’t end being overcorrected.
So, using a no-bark training collar is certainly safe. All you really need to decide upon is whether or not you’re comfortable with the idea of your dog receiving gentle static shocks. If you are, use these collars knowing you’re not going to hurt your dog in any serious way. If you aren’t comfortable with the idea, road test the other training collars using sound, vibration, or spray.
Right then, it’s time for the main event with our curated list of the 10 best no bark collars…
IV. The 10 Best Anti-Bark Collars
1. Best Anti Bark Collar with Remote (Works Manually): Dog Care Rechargeable Shock Collar
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/dp/B075FV9Z6B/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
If you want to start training your pooch remotely, this rechargeable and multipurpose collar from Dog Care is well worth popping on your shortlist.
A trio of training modes allows you to use an audible beep, gentle vibration, or a static shock to discourage your furball from barking excessively. Rotate between these training methods so you can find what works best for your dog.
Rather than repeating this for each of the anti-bark collars we feature today, you should always use positive reinforcement to complement correction. Just like in the old fable, the carrot is equally as important as the stick.
Have you got several dogs at home? If so, this unit can support up to 9 collars on a single transmitter. This gives you the ability to correct behavior remotely without investing in a complete set for each of your pets.
Wireless range extends fully 350 feet so you’re amply covered even if you’re walking your dogs in a spacious park, Runtime is as much as 15 days with an impressive 45-day standby period.
IP65 waterproof-rated, this collar is fit to withstand some serious punishment.
Whether you’re looking to train your dog not to bark or to teach him to obey in various other settings, this training collar is a fitting addition to any arsenal.
2. Best Static Bark Collar (Best for Effectiveness): SportDOG No-Bark 10R Collar
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00SW8Y30K/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
If you’re looking for the best no-bark collar, SportDOG has a hard-won reputation for delivering top-notch pet products on a budget. Is this collar any good beyond the attractive price tag, though?
This collar is suitable for all dogs weighing 8 pounds and upward with neck sized between 6 and 28 inches. The waterproof plastic collar won’t irritate your pooch’s neck and is ideal for use in all winds and weathers.
SportDOG offers 10 levels of static correction. While you can find collars with much more choice on this front, this selection should be more than fit for purpose.
If your dog starts barking more than 15 times a minute in any mode, the collar automatically powers down for 3 minutes. This gives you peace of mind that your precious pooch won’t be subjected to a barrage of correction.
Correction will only be delivered when vibration from the vocal chords is felt along with noise issuing from the bark. This double layer of protection makes this one of the most effective anti-bark collars on the market.
For a hardwearing, reliable, and highly effective no-bark collar, SportDOG dominate this vertical with just cause.
3. Best Spray Anti Bark Collar (Safest, Works Manually): PetSafe Remote Pet Spray Trainer
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07JGBFCW9/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
Maybe you don’t like the idea of giving your beloved dog a static shock. That said, you might have found collars delivering nothing but sound or vibration to be ineffective. What can you do?
Well, this spray no-bark collar from the highly reputable PetSafe gives you a humane training solution giving your day no pain just the discomfort of a sprayed snout.
Choose from citronella or unscented cartridges. Dogs loathe citronella so make sure yours isn’t too disgusted by the citrus smell. Unscented spray works just fine so it’s a question of finding which provokes the best reaction in your pup.
Lightweight, compact, and waterproof, you can leave this collar on your pooch for hours without causing any discomfort.
The battery has 40 hours of runtime and the cartridges each contain 35 measured sprays.
In terms of sizings, you’ll need your dog to have at least an 8-inch neck to fit into this collar. For larger dogs, this collar is good with neck sizes to 28 inches.
With 30 years in the business, you can buy from PetSafe with complete confidence. If you run into any problems, you should find the US-based customer care is helpful and responsive.
4. Best Budget: DogRook Bark Collar
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B072DS462V/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
If you’re looking to keep your dog from barking around the clock and you don’t have too much money to spare, this DogRook no-bark collar is a neat solution.
You can choose from audible beeps or vibration with this humane collar that doesn’t involve any form of static shock.
Tweak the collar to fit almost all dogs from small to large breeds. The plastic prongs shouldn’t irritate your pooch’s skin either.
While using remote-controlled training collars can be undeniably effective, it can also be a little restrictive carrying the remote itself. Go hands-free and let this intelligent collar correct your dog’s excessive barking automatically.
This collar is ideally suited for a wide range of dogs from 8 pounds through 110 pounds. The collar fits neck sizes from 9 inches to 22 inches so you have plenty of scope with sizings.
Train your dog using high-pitched tones and a choice of 7 vibration levels so he soon gets the message when it’s not appropriate to keep barking.
The water-resistant strap is ideal if you live somewhere with inclement weather conditions or you happen to walk your pooch near water.
For a great all-round training collar that’s totally humane and priced attractively, the DogRook is a must.
5. Best for Small Dogs: PetSafe Elite Bark Control Collar
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004HKMEX0/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
PetSafe is a dominant force in this vertical with the Elite sitting at the upper end of their range.
With a choice of 10 levels of correction to step through, you can use the gentle force of controlled static shocks to show your dog when it’s time to stop barking. Auto shut-off will stop shocks being delivered after 80 seconds so your furball is in no danger of being overstimulated.
Bark detection is highly intelligent and you shouldn’t be menaced by false positives. The collar can even tune out the sound of other neighborhood dogs barking so your bundle of furry joy doesn’t get blamed when he isn’t even barking.
This model is designed for small to medium dogs with an upper weight limit of just 55 pounds and a maximum neck size of 16 inches. Look for a beefier collar if you need to train large breeds.
As with most decent no-bark collars, you’ll get a waterproof unit giving you plenty of flexibility. The collar is submersible to 5 feet so will sustain a quick dip in the sea.
For a solid all-rounder ideal for small to medium dogs, PetSafe smash another home run with the Elite.
6. Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe Rechargeable Dog Training Collar
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00B2GDC8S/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
Best know for their fitness trackers and GPS, Garmin bring that tech expertise to bear on this nifty dog training collar.
You can flick between using vibration for correction or allowing progressive static shocks to persuade your furball to comply. Stainless steel contact points for the collar are highly durable while guaranteed not to irritate your dog’s neck.
Garmin’s BarkLimiter picks up on barking based entirely on the vibrations coming through your dog’s throat. This slashes the chance of false positives to almost nothing and gives you and your pooch the most seamless experience.
If you’re looking for plug-and-play ease, Autorise starts correcting your dog and stops as soon as it becomes effective so minimizing your dog’s exposure to static shocks.
The Deluxe model here weighs only 2oz so your dog won’t feel like she’s wearing a collar at all.
Rechargeable batteries are a neat touch that reduces ongoing running costs.
The collar is designed to fit dogs of all breeds and sizes. It also fits with all thicknesses of coat. You’ll get a highly versatile training collar from a brand you can trust.
7. PetYeah Dog Bark Collar
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07M6KF55L/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
This training collar is a real bargain while still keeping quality uppermost. What makes it stand out?
You get a versatile training solution with a choice of 2 modes:
- Beep and Vibration: This totally humane training mode combines audible beeps with a vibration to help dissuade your pooch from barking
- Beep and Vibration with Shock: This mode adds in static shocks on a progressive scale with shocks becoming more intense until barking stops for 30 seconds
Bark recognition is sound and you shouldn’t find yourself menaced with false positives.
The manufacturer suggest this collar should not be used with aggressive dogs so bear this in mind. For all other dogs of regular temperament, this collar allows for a wide range of training at a price you won’t believe.
Reflective strips around the collar make this a great night-time training aid. IP67-rated, the collar is waterproof so fit for use in the rain or if your dog takes a quick dip.
You’ll be able to generate a full burst of charge in 2 hours and this yields a generous 10 days of runtime.
As long as you don’t leave this collar on for more than 12 hours a day, it should become a valuable part of your training arsenal.
8. Best Ultrasonic Bark Collar: FirstAlert Bark Genie
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00E0J58FY/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
Perhaps you don’t like the idea of using static shock correction on your beloved pedigree pooch but you find that vibration collars simply don’t have the desired effect. Maybe you find the same lack of results from spray collars. Luckily, FirstAlert’s nifty Bark Genie lets you make use of ultrasonic sound to correct aberrant behavior.
If you’re concerned about the sound bothering you, you needn’t be. Ultrasonic sound waves are beyond our hearing frequencies but piercingly effective for dog’s sensitive ears. Despite delivering a jolt of sound, there’s no accompanying static shock so you can train your dog with a clear conscience.
Range is somewhat limited so you’ll need to remain within 15 feet of your dog to issue the warning.
This training device is designed to work well on all breeds of dogs. You can train large or small dogs with equal ease.
Despite what you might think to the contrary, this type of device is a smart move if you have an aggressive dog. Often, using static shock makes feisty dogs even worse.
You’ll need 4 x AAA batteries to run this device and you don’t get these included. Make provision if you want to get going right out the box.
9. Dogtra YS300 Rechargeable Bark Collar
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/dp/B004M8LM44/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
Dogtra has a solid reputation for producing powerful pet accessories at an affordable price range but is the YS300 a worthwhile anti-bark collar?
Absolutely. The slimline plastic collar is lightweight and won’t irritate your furball’s skin. Waterproofed, too, you can use this training aid in all winds and weathers, and even down by the beach.
You’ll need your dog to weigh at least 10 pounds for this collar to fit neatly. You can train medium and large dogs with no problem.
6 levels of static correction give you a decent chance of ramping up the shock if your dog doesn’t comply.
If you want to use vibration-only mode, the collar becomes a humane training tool suitable for those who dislike the idea of static shocks.
A pair of rechargeable batteries take just 2 hours to juice up then return days of happy training.
As with all training collars, it’s crucial not to forget the positive reinforcement. Instead of simply punishing your dog for barking too much, throw in plenty of hugs and handfuls of treats when he obeys and cuts the barking out.
10. Rechargeable Bark Collar for Dogs
[su_button url=”https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07DGZJX6B/?tag=” target=”blank” background=”#f44336″ size=”7″ center=”yes” rel=”nofollow”]VIEW AT AMAZON[/su_button]
This training collar is designed to work well with dogs from 15 pounds up to 120 pounds so you have plenty of flexibility.
Priced in budget territory, how about performance?
You’ll get 3 choices of correction:
This gives you complete versatility in a single training collar and renders the unit perfect for all types and temperament of dog.
Plenty of safety features come baked in to ensure your pooch won’t end up overcorrected.
Waterproofed, you can take your dog out when it’s raining and it won’t matter if she takes a dip in the ocean either. Take your dog anywhere confident she won’t continue barking endlessly.
Battery-operated, you can expect up to a fortnight of training from a single charge so you won’t be constantly fussing around. Let’s face it, it’s enough hassle keeping your cellphone charged daily without another device constantly demanding your attention.
You should not use this collar for pups under 6 months, sick, or aggressive dogs. For all other use cases, this is a pocket-friendly collar that punches above its weight.
With that snapshot of the strongest pet training collars in place, it’s time to round out with the things you should focus on when you’re on the buying trail…
V. Things to Look For When Buying a Bark Control Collar
As we stated front and center, buying a dog training collar can be confusing if you don’t know what you’re looking for.
Double down on these elements and you’ll simplify your buying decision no end:
- Type of Collar
- Method of Control
- Intensity Settings
- Range of Signal
- Training Several Dogs with One Receiver
- Sizing Counts
Type of Collar
As we mentioned, you can find training collars that deliver varying corrections to your furry friend.
Static shock collars give your pooch a burst of static similar to the static shocks you pick up yourself from time to time. You may or not find the idea of this form of correction acceptable. That’s down to you and we’ll say nothing to try to convince you in either direction.
Vibration collars replace the static shock with a pulse of vibration that should gently dissuade your furball from creating mayhem.
With a spray collar, excessive barking triggers a spray of citronella or other liquid to saturate your dog’s snout without hurting him. He should soon stop barking inappropriately with citronella in the house!
An ultrasonic device corrects your pooch using sound waves inaudible to the human ear but enervating to your dog.
Method of Control
Remote control training collars give you the flexibility to deliver manual correction if your dog is playing up.
An always-on collar, by contrast, is the perfect training device if your dogs spend plenty of time alone when you’re out at work.
Large and stubborn dogs sometimes need firmer encouragement to behave appropriately.
Some collars give you 100 levels of shock intensity but in all honesty this is overkill. As long as you have a reasonable band to choose from, you can use progressive correction until you reach your desired result.
Range of Signal
Some collars have range limited to 15 feet. As such, these are only beneficial for close-quarters training.
Other training collars boast impressive ranges of anywhere from 300 to 1000 feet. These are tailor-made for use in parks, fields or down on the beach.
All that counts here is getting enough range for your needs.
Training Several Dogs with One Receiver
Have you got more than one dog at home?
If so, you probably don’t want the expense of buying multiple training collars from scratch. It would also be awkward juggling remotes.
If you have several pets, look for a training device that allows you to buy collars and use them with a single remote control.
You should check that your dog falls within the suggested weight range for the collar you’re looking at. Most collars work with dogs of 8 to 10 pounds and above.
If you have an especially large breed, check the upper weight limit, too.
The other metric that counts with collars is neck size. Again, check that your pooch has a neck sized within the range of the collar you’re considering.
Many of the best anti-bark collars are waterproofed and submersible.
For any dog owners often outside in the rain or for dogs prone to jumping in the ocean, this type of all-weather collar is key.
Check that any display on the collar is easy to read day and night.
VI. Tips for Using an Anti-Bark Collar
Many pet owners buy a collar online and think that’s mission accomplished.
Unfortunately, training takes a little effort upfront but you’ll end up reaping the rewards as you move down the track.
Excessive barking is an annoyance that needn’t be tolerated.
Here’s how to start obedience training before you even have your training collar in place…
Get Started Without a Collar
The most difficult thing about many projects is simply getting started.
You can get going right away if you want to start discouraging your dog from barking so what do you do?
When your dog is barking too much or at the wrong time, verbally reprimand him every time.
If he listens and dials it back, reward him with a hug or a treat. Or both!
This is a good way to warm up for when you start using a training collar of your chosen type.
Keep Positive Reinforcement Uppermost
You should remember at all times that positive reinforcement will be just as useful when you’re training your dog as punishment.
There’s no doubt that punitive measures can pay dividends but you’ll get better results if you mix the carrot with the stick.
Get The Right Collar For The Job
Collars can help correct excessive barking by administering ultrasonic tones, pulsing vibrations, static shocks, or sprays of citrus.
All that’s important is getting what you perceive to be the right anti-bark collar for your dog. There’s no one-size-fits-all solution.
You’ll also need to give due consideration to how you want the correction administered…
Are you looking for a hands-on training device equipped with a remote control?
Do you prefer instead the idea of an always-on device to correct aberrant barking when you’re not at home?
Take your time at this stage so you maximize the chances of getting an appropriate dog training collar rather than something that ends up gathering dust in the closet.
Don’t Be Tempted to Over-Correct
We’ve thrown this next pointer in since many pet owners buy a collar that doesn’t really work then get frustrated and ratchet up the intensity too much.
This can lead to worse behavior than ever as well as hurting your dog so avoid the temptation to over-correct.
Sometimes, you might need to accept a training method isn’t working and disband its use.
If you’re not sure how your dog will respond, think about buying a multipurpose collar affording you a choice of correction methods.
Take Full Advantage of Progressive Correction
There’s a good reason that anti-bark collars come with progressive levels of static correction.
Always start gently and work your way up if the gentler shock doesn’t have the desired effect.
If you start at the upper end of the threshold, the shock can be unnecessarily robust so work slowly upward.
Avoid Shock Collars If You Have a Aggressive Dog
You might feel a static shock collar is the only answer if you have an aggressive dog who won’t stop barking.
This is not advisable and you’re quite likely to notice behavior worsening.
The best advice we can give you if you have an extremely wilful or aggressive dog is to enlist the services of a great dog trainer. Even if you only have one or two sessions, you can pick up some valuable tips and apply them to improve your dog’s behavior with a little expert knowledge thrown in.
To round out today, we’ve collected the most frequently asked questions about no-bark collars and answered them for you…
1) What is a no-bark collar?
No-bark collars come under many names. You might also see them referred to as dog training collars, shock collars, or anti-bark collars. These collars come in many different varieties. Correction is administered by static shock, ultrasonic beeps, pulsing vibrations or sprays of citronella. Regardless of the method of correction, the core purpose of these collars is the same: to stop dogs from barking excessively.
2) What does positive reinforcement mean?
When you’re training your dog, whether it’s to stop barking excessively, to sit or to obey other commands, using punishment alone as a training strategy is not only cruel but ineffective. Incorporate reward when your dog is obedient and that’s positive reinforcement for you. This is the kindest and also by far the most effective overarching training strategy. You can never give your furball too many hugs or too many treats. Reward good behavior at all times.
3) Is it safe to use a static shock collar on my dog?
Yes. Using a static shock collar will deliver a short, sharp shock of similar intensity to the static shocks you receive yourself from time to time. While this will not cause any serious or lasting pain, some pet owners find the idea of these collars inhumane. There really is no right or wrong answer here. If you feel comfortable administering this type of low-level shock when you’re training your pooch, there are plenty of great collars that are all perfectly safe to use.
4) Do spray collars really work?
They certainly do. Most of these collars use a citronella spray. Dogs are not fans of citrus scents and your canine won’t appreciate a snout full of lemon. You can also use an unscented spray since dogs don’t like their snouts getting wet. Either way, if your dog is barking too much, it won’t take too many bursts of citronella spray for him to mend his ways.
5) What is an always-on training collar?
Unlike remote control training collars, you leave an always-on collar in place. The sensors onboard ensure that your pooch is corrected for barking too much even if you’re not around. Safety measures in place and auto shut-off removes any chance of your dog being over-corrected. This type of collar is perfect if your dog is prone to barking and spends long spells unattended. You should not use this type of collar for more than 12 hours in one stretch.
6) I have more than one dog. Can I train all 4 of my dogs with one collar?
You’ll need to buy separate collars but many of the units we look at today allow you to use a single remote receiver along with additional collars. You’ll save money this way and you’ll also only need one remote control.
7) What should I do if my dog’s neck looks irritated after using the collar?
Occasionally, you might find your dog is sensitive to the prongs on these training collars. Make sure you always keep the prongs clean and disinfected. Check the skin around the collar and keep an eye on your dog itching and scratching. If you find your dog is intolerant to the collar, you should immediately discontinue use.
8) Is it acceptable to use a training collar on a puppy?
It’s not, no. You should wait until your dog is at least 6 months old before embarking on a training program that calls for a no-bark collar.
9) Do ultrasonic devices really work?
This type of correction device can work, yes. Usually handheld and effective only over short range, the high-pitched sounds might not register on your radar but your dog will find the noise unpleasant enough that she should modify her behavior.
10) What’s the best no-bark collar?
There isn’t a single collar we could term the best. All that counts is finding what works for your dog. If you’re uncertain where to start, we would strongly recommend investing in a multipurpose collar that gives you a choice of correction methods. You can then assess which works best.
Well, by now you should be completely clear on how the various types of dog training collar. You should also have an accurate idea of which variety would make the most effective training device for your canine.
This is one purchase you shouldn’t rush into. Give close consideration to the temperament of your dog and whether or not they have responded to other forms of correction. Time spent before purchase can easily save you from wasting your money.
Once you have the collar in place, pay attention to some of the hints we outlined above and you should find your dog stops barking excessively in relatively little time.
Come back soon! We’re just starting out but we have an ambitious content schedule in place so we’ll soon be your go-to resource for all things pet-related.